US judge clears brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case after mistrial

US judge clears brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case after mistrial

A US federal judge has acquitted two brothers who were accused of extracting about $25 million from automated Ethereum trading bots. The ruling ends a prosecution that tested whether exploiting the mechanics of blockchain transaction ordering can amount to criminal fraud.

In a ruling issued on Monday, November 16, 2026, US District Judge Jessica Clarke of the Southern District of New York granted a judgment of acquittal to Anton and James Peraire-Bueno. The brothers are MIT-educated. Clarke acquitted them on wire fraud and related charges and also dismissed a money laundering conspiracy charge tied to the case. She found that prosecutors failed to establish that the brothers made a material misrepresentation, which is a necessary element of wire fraud.

Prosecutors had alleged that in April 2023 the brothers exploited a vulnerability in the relay infrastructure of MEV-Boost. MEV-Boost is software that lets Ethereum validators outsource the ordering of transactions to specialized block builders. According to the allegations, the brothers used that weakness to target so-called sandwich bots. These automated traders profit from maximal extractable value (MEV) by placing their own trades on either side of other users' transactions. Prosecutors said the brothers gained access to the bots' private transaction bundles and replaced the proposed block contents with their own transactions. The bots were left with large losses. Reporting on the case says the operation netted roughly $25 million in about 12 seconds. One outlet reports that the strategy was called Omakase.

In her opinion, Clarke wrote that the question before the court was not whether the brothers' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes. She described Ethereum as a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use. The judge acknowledged that the scheme may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost. She concluded that this did not amount to fraud under the statutes prosecutors had charged. She also rejected the argument that submitting an invalid block header with a digital signature was itself a material misrepresentation.

The acquittal follows a long procedural path. The brothers were arrested in May 2024. Authorities said they planned the attack for months and took steps to conceal the proceeds, and an insider testified at trial that the brothers had plotted the exploit. Defense lawyers tried to exclude certain evidence, including Google searches. In November 2025 the judge declared a mistrial after the jury deadlocked. Prosecutors had since sought a retrial. The new judgment closes the criminal case and removes that possibility, according to FinanceFeeds.

The decision is narrow in scope. Clarke stressed that she was ruling only on whether the specific charges were met. She did not decide whether the conduct was ethical or whether it might violate other laws. Even so, the case drew close attention from developers, validators and traders. It addressed how existing fraud statutes apply to adversarial behavior on public blockchains, where code rather than contractual terms governs what is possible.

This article is a news summary and is not financial, investment or tax advice.

This is a news summary for general information only — not financial advice, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any asset. Always verify against the original source and do your own research before making a financial decision.

Source: Cointelegraph · 2026-11-18